Batgirl: The Darkest Reflection by Gail Simone
I decided to try Batgirl
for two reasons. I wanted to try another comic from the New 52 to see how I
would enjoy it, and I wanted to read more Gail Simone after sort of shying away
from her writing because of a volume of The
Atom I read that made me want to run away screaming. Friends and fans of
Gail assured me that I would enjoy either Birds
of Prey or Batgirl much more than
I enjoyed The Atom. After some
resistance, I finally decided it was time to close my eyes and step off this
cliff again.
The Darkest Reflection
follows Barbara Gordon who has made her return as Batgirl after an experimental—or
at least it sounded experimental—medical procedure returns her ability to use
her legs. For those of you not quite familiar with what happened or only have a
vague idea of what happened to her, refer to The Killing Joke
pre-DCnU. After some downtime rehabbing while living in her father’s home,
Barbara decides that it’s time to spread her wings, move out of her father’s
house, and take up the mantle of the bat again. What Barbara didn’t count on
was her survivor’s guilt and PTSD (which is triggered when she’s faced with
guns) making her return to crime fighting more difficult than she’d expected.
I enjoyed this much, much, much more than I did The Atom. At first, I was a little
afraid that I might have to put this book down because it started a bit campier
that I like. Actually, no, I should explain that better. I love when writers
use campy writing to their advantage, but sometimes, I feel like writer’s try too hard with it. In turn, that turns me
off because it comes off feeling so artificial and forced and makes it hard for
me to enjoy the story. This was one of
the main problems that I had with The
Atom. There were points in the beginning of this story where I worried I
might be traveling down that road again, but after a while, the story found its
footing and turned into an enjoyable read.
Barbara is a survivor struggling with the thought of having her
legs back. She struggles with conflicting feelings that make her feel blessed
for this miracle, but questions why did she, out of all the people in the in
the world, deserve such a miracle. After thwarting a murder attempt on a
family, Barbara’s next foe challenges her miracle as well and brings out deeper
psychological fears.
I really enjoyed the portrayal of Barbara’s struggle. She’s of two minds for
most of this comic. She’s a superwoman and a frail all in the same
breath. One minute she’s praising herself for her strength and smarts, and the next
minute, she doubts herself and if she’s even doing the right thing. She wonders
if she’s squandering her miracle by pushing herself too hard, but then she
feels that this miracle wasn’t given to her for her to sit by idly. A brief
confrontation with Nightwing shows the feelings she stills hold for him while
punctuating that she doesn’t want the others to believe that she’s not capable--to the point that she lashes out at him in order to show that she isn’t
helpless. She doesn’t want their help. She wants to prove herself, her strength
and ability to overcome, to the bat family.
Let me talk briefly about the ending of this comic. No real
spoilers, but just some thoughts. When I realized that Barbara’s threat was
eliminated in the fourth issues but there were still two issues left in this arc,
I was thinking, “Okay?” It ended perfectly, and I was thinking that things were
about to get odd since what could you possibly accomplish in two more issues? I
was pleasantly surprised. You can say the next two issues in the arc were a
mini-story, but still tied into the “reflection” theme showing Barbara what she
could’ve been if she hadn’t had family and support.
The first part dealt with accepting that miracles happened
to people whether they deserved them or not and that there’s no one who can decide
that someone is undeserving of such a miracle, even if it’s a personal miracle.
The second part dealt more personally with the idea that not everyone may see his
or her miracle as a miracle. It showed how fragile the line between miracle and
damnation is in some people’s mind, and it showed a thing about compassion and understanding, as well.
Overall, this was entertaining. There were some hiccups for
me, and I’m back to questioning why it’s so easy for some people to find out
who the bat family is over other more intelligent criminals. That's a general annoyance of mine with Batman and the bat family, not something that's limited to Gail herself. However, I still
enjoyed the story and appreciated it for showing Barbara’s return as a struggle
that she’s working to overcome for physical and psychological reasons. I’ll
definitely read more of the Batgirl
books.
Final Verdict:
3 of 5 stars
No comments :
Post a Comment